Please Note: This post is focusing on pre-C99. The reason being is that it is aimed at the embedded C programmer who tends to be working with pre-C99 based cross-compilers. Also I have split it into two as it became my larger, due to feedback, than first anticipated.

On the surface declarations and definitions in C are pretty straight-forward; but once we start introducing the concepts of scope, storage-duration, linkage and namespace life is not so simple.

Program Objects (Variables)

Object Definitions

int ev = 20; /* definition – reserves enough memory to hold an int */

Object Declaration

Usage

When compiling a source file, a variable must be declared before it is used or it will result in a compiler error.

int main(void)
{
   ev = 10; /* fails to compile as ev has not been declared */
   return 0;
}
int ev = 20; /* definition – allocates 32-bits */

int ev = 20; /* definition and implicit-declaration: reserves memory */
int main(void) 
{
   ev = 10; /* okay to use ev as declared (implicitly) */ 
   return 0; 
}

extern int ev; /* 1st declaration */
extern int ev; /* 2nd declaration */

int ev = 20; /* actual definition    */
int td;      /* tentative definition */

If an actual definition is found later in the source file, then the tentative definition just acts as a declaration. If the end of the source file is reached and no actual definition is found, then the tentative definition acts as an actual definition (and implicit declaration) with an initialisation of 0 (zero).

int ev; /* tentative definition becomes declaration */
int td; /* tentative definition become actual definition initialised to 0 */
int main(void)
{
   ...
   return 0;
}

int ev = 20; /* actual definition */

I’m sure someone can (and will) tell me why this is useful, but in my 25 years of doing C I’ve never had need to use it. I my view anyone found doing this should be made to sit in the corner wearing a hat with a big ‘D’ on it!

Functions

Function declarations and definitions are in many ways simpler than variables. A function definition includes the function’s body. e.g.

void f(int p) /* definition and implicit-declaration */
{
   ...
}

int main(void)
{
   f(10); /* okay to call f as declared */
   return 0;
}

A function’s declaration (typically called its prototype) makes the compiler aware there is a valid function with this identifier. e.g.

void f(int p); /* declaration */

int main(void)
{
   f(10); /* okay to call f as declared */
   return 0;
}

void f(int p) /* definition */
{
   // ...
}

Before we move on, there are two problem areas we need to cover. First, let’s look at the following snippet:

int main()
{
   f(20); /* call f with no declaration */
   return 0;
}

void f(int i) /* definition and implicit-declaration */
{
   // ...
}

Here we are trying to call a function that hasn’t been declared. As probably expected, this code fails to compile, but not for the reason you probably assume. Earlier I stated that an identifier must be declared before being used otherwise you get a compiler error. Unfortunately this only applies to variables and not functions!

f(20);

int f();

error: ‘f’ : redefinition; different basic types

If we change f’s return type to int, then this code will compile quite happily.

int main(void)
{
   f(20); /* call f implicit-designator of int f() */
   return 0;
}

int f(int i) /* definition’s designator matches implicit-designator */
{
   // ...
}

This baggage is still evident today, as the following code should compile successfully:

int main()
{
   f(20); /* call f implicit-designator of int f() */
   return 0;
}

f(int i) /* definition’s designator has implicit return type of int */
{
   // ...
}

Never ignore this warning. Some compilers (such as IAR) allow a non-standard extension requiring function prototypes. Note that C++ also requires prototypes, thus closing this loophole.

Can it get worse? Oh yes, much worse.

With a function definition, then empty parameter list is the same as void.

void f()       /* definition and implicit-decln of void f(void) */
{
   // ...
}

int main()
{
   f(20);       /* error as call doesn’t match decln */
   return 0;
}

void f(); /* declaration */

void f(); /* declaration */

Guideline: For all function always supply a function-prototype.

So hopefully that lays the groundwork of declarations and definitions we can now start addressing the concepts of scope, storage-duration, linkage and namespace.

Afternote:

void f()      /* definition and implicit-decln of void f(void) */
{
   // ...
}

int main(void)
{
   f(20);       /* error a call doesn’t match decln */
   return 0;
}